By Joshua Bodwell
Photography Darren Setlow
Styling Tamara Savage
Kitchen Islands at the Heart of the Home’s Heart
A large, wooden table was once a common fixture in the kitchens of our forebears. The tables provided much-needed room to spread out ingredients and cookware, and it was a gathering place within the warm thrum of kitchen activity. These well-worn tables were the precursors of today’s ubiquitous kitchen island, which may just be the defining feature of modern kitchens. Pamela Shangraw-Murdough of Kennebunk Kitchens and Baths loves how islands “redirect kitchen traffic” and separate those who are cooking or cleaning from those who are eating or gabbing. According to Shangraw-Murdough, space is often the most important consideration when selecting an appropriate design. An island, she says, must remain proportional to the size of the kitchen: too big, and there’s no clearance; too small, and there’s no space to prep, cook, or eat.
Once the size has been determined, Shangraw-Murdough often outfits her islands by first seeing what she can or cannot place in other areas of the kitchen. Some decisions are easier than others; if there is no window with an outside view, she says, the decision to put the sink in the island is an easy one.
In addition to the essentials, such as stools and extra space for storage, Shangraw-Murdough says kitchen islands are often best suited for smaller, under-the-counter appliances like microwaves, warming draws, or wine refrigerators.
For Todd McIntosh of McIntosh & Tuttle Cabinetmakers, designing and building kitchen islands combines two passions. “I love cooking,” he says. “If I’m not in the woodshop, I’m in the kitchen.”
When it comes to selecting hardware for kitchen-island cabinetry, McIntosh offers pragmatic advice: “Keep it simple.” He usually steers people away from “gimmicky hardware with too many moving parts.” While the flashier hardware might be interesting to look at, McIntosh notes, it often has a shorter life-span than something simpler.
When it comes to kitchen islands, McIntosh also suggests letting the natural wood shine. Since kitchens are such high-traffic areas, he says, painted islands are easily scuffed and marred. Square corners are another feature best avoided: “I try to use rounded or chamfered corners, or even columns. People just don’t move at right angles, so having some rounded parts can be important.”
When deciding what material to use atop your island, Morningstar Marble & Granite owner Nick Whatley makes a case for stone. “The longevity of it goes beyond anything any of us can imagine,” he says. Whatley also mentions a few key things to keep in mind when searching for the perfect piece of stone.
Though stone is a strong and stable material, Whatley warns that marble or granite should overhang the island by no more than ten inches without adding supporting features such as brackets or legs. “I like people to understand how this fact will figure into the design and everyday use of their island,” says Whatley. He also warns that large or heavy kitchen islands may require floors to be reinforced from below. “If you have cabinetry, a range-top, and granite, you could be talking 700 pounds in the middle of a room,” he says.
Beyond its longevity and practicality, Whatley also loves stone simply for its beauty. “A granite- or marble-topped island can be like a painting,” he says. “The size really gives stone a chance to shine.”
And who doesn’t want their kitchen island to shine—from layout to hardware to countertop—like a work of art?